SHOCKING TRUTH: ED GEIN WAS A BABYSITTER AND THIS IS WHAT HE DID

SHOCKING TRUTH: ED GEIN WAS A BABYSITTER AND THIS IS WHAT HE DID

Did you know that one of America's most notorious serial killers once babysat for local children in his Wisconsin community? The story of Ed Gein is filled with chilling details that blur the lines between fact and fiction, but perhaps none is more disturbing than his role as a trusted caretaker for neighborhood kids.

When we think of Ed Gein, images of grave robbing, human taxidermy, and inspiration for horror classics like Psycho and The Texas Chainsaw Massacre come to mind. But the reality is far more complex and unsettling than fiction could ever portray.

Biography of Ed Gein

Full NameEdward Theodore Gein
BornAugust 27, 1906
DiedJuly 26, 1984
BirthplaceLa Crosse County, Wisconsin, USA
Known ForSerial killing, grave robbing, human taxidermy
NicknameThe Butcher of Plainfield
Criminal StatusDeclared mentally incompetent, died in psychiatric institution

The Truth Behind the Babysitter Myth

The Netflix series Monster has reignited interest in Ed Gein's crimes, but it's important to separate fact from fiction. While the series depicts Gein killing his brother Henry, babysitter Evelyn Hartley, two hunters, and a nurse at the hospital where he was confined, not all of these events actually occurred.

Yes, Ed Gein actually did babysit for local children in his Wisconsin community. His role as a babysitter for neighbor kids is a really chilling and true fact. A retiring handyman, not a professional babysitter, Ed Gein performed odd jobs for neighbors in his tiny hometown, fixing fences, mending tools, and assisting occasionally with chores. He was known as reserved and a little strange handyman, but his quiet demeanor masked the darkness within.

The Evelyn Hartley Case: Fact or Fiction?

The disappearance of Evelyn Hartley, a babysitter who vanished in La Crosse, Wisconsin in 1953, has often been linked to Ed Gein in popular culture. The story has become legend—a beautiful young woman vanishes into the Wisconsin night, never to be seen again, her name whispered like a ghost in the night.

However, there is no concrete evidence linking Ed Gein to Evelyn Hartley's disappearance. While Gein was in the area at the time and was questioned about the case, authorities never established a definitive connection. The Evelyn Hartley case remains unsolved, and while it makes for compelling storytelling, attributing it to Gein is more fiction than fact.

The Brother Henry Controversy

Speaking of babysitting, another murder that Gein is portrayed as committing in Monster is that of his brother Henry. Did Ed Gein kill his brother? This question has haunted true crime enthusiasts for decades.

Ed Gein, the infamous Butcher of Plainfield, is known for his undeniably gruesome crimes, but the circumstances surrounding his brother Henry's death are shrouded in mystery and speculation. Henry Gein died in 1944 under what many consider suspicious circumstances. Officially, his death was attributed to asphyxiation while fighting a brush fire, but some investigators and amateur sleuths believe otherwise.

The truth is that Henry's death was never officially ruled a homicide, though many find the circumstances suspicious. Ed was the last person seen with Henry, and some witnesses reported seeing Ed behaving oddly after his brother's death. However, without concrete evidence, this remains one of the many mysteries surrounding Ed Gein's life.

The Fictional Hospital Murder

One of the most shocking scenes in Monster shows the Butcher of Plainfield striking again—this time inside a psychiatric hospital, murdering a head nurse in cold blood. The Ed Gein story shows the killer striking again—murdering a nurse inside the psychiatric hospital where he was held.

But the reality is very different. Ed Gein was never known to have killed anyone while institutionalized. This dramatic scene, while compelling television, appears to be pure fiction created for dramatic effect. The series creates its own fictional and more exaggerated interpretations of their possible interactions.

What Ed Gein Actually Did

So who was killer Ed Gein and what did he do? The Ed Gein story focuses on the serial killer and grave robber who inspired some of Hollywood's darkest films. Here's who Ed Gein was and what he actually did:

  • Grave Robbing: Gein admitted to exhuming bodies from local cemeteries, particularly those of middle-aged women who reminded him of his mother.
  • Human Taxidermy: He created disturbing trophies and keepsakes from human skin and bones.
  • Murder: Gein confessed to killing two women: Mary Hogan in 1954 and Bernice Worden in 1957.
  • Psychological Disturbance: Ed lived in a fantasy world, often blurring the lines between reality and his disturbing fantasies.

The psychological evaluations of Ed Gein have revealed a man with a fragmented sense of self and a profound disconnection from reality. His interactions with others were limited, and he struggled to form healthy relationships. The Ed Gein story that were made up, and Netflix got completely wrong, often stems from the public's fascination with extreme deviance and the desire to create a more dramatic narrative than reality provides.

The Truth About His Victims

Among Gein's confirmed victims was Mary Hogan, 54, who ran a tavern that Gein frequented. Her disappearance in 1954 was one of the cases that eventually led authorities to Gein's doorstep. Bernice Worden, a hardware store owner, was his final victim in 1957, and her murder led to his arrest.

The Ed Gein story told her case true and is accurate when it comes to these confirmed victims. However, the series' depiction of additional murders, including the fictional nurse killing and the Evelyn Hartley case, represents creative liberties taken with the historical record.

Separating Fact from Fiction

The shocking true story of Ed Gein, the original 'Psycho,' released with a new book cover in the spring, reminds us that even in his own book Deviant: The Shocking True Story of Ed Gein, the Original Psycho, author Harold Schechter created imaginative reconstructions to depict what might have gone on between Ed and his mother Augusta.

The series creates its own fictional and more exaggerated interpretations of their possible interactions. This is common in true crime adaptations, where dramatic effect often takes precedence over historical accuracy.

Conclusion

The Ed Gein story is a complex tapestry of fact and fiction, truth and speculation. While it's true that Ed Gein was a babysitter and handyman in his community, his crimes were far less extensive than popular culture sometimes suggests. The Netflix series Monster explores the serial killer's gruesome crimes, but some parts are pure fiction designed for dramatic effect.

What really happened to babysitter Evelyn Hartley remains a mystery, and while the Ed Gein story has been linked to her case, the connection is more urban legend than established fact. The truth about Ed Gein is disturbing enough without the need for fictional embellishments.

As we continue to grapple with the legacy of America's most infamous killers, it's crucial to separate fact from fiction, understanding that the reality of these cases is often more nuanced and complex than the sensationalized versions presented in popular media. The Ed Gein story, like many true crime narratives, reminds us that truth can be stranger—and sometimes less dramatic—than fiction.

The Babysitter - Monster: The Ed Gein Story 1x03 | TVmaze
Unhinged: The Shocking True Story of Ed Gein, The Butcher of Plainfield
Deviant: The Shocking True Story of Ed Gein, the Original Psycho