The term in question refers to legal professionals in Spokane who have achieved a high level of recognition and success in the field of divorce law. These attorneys typically possess extensive experience, a strong track record of favorable outcomes for their clients, and a reputation for ethical and effective representation. For example, a lawyer who consistently secures advantageous settlements or victories in court proceedings related to divorce cases within the Spokane area could be described using this descriptor.
Selecting highly qualified legal counsel is a critical decision during divorce proceedings. Competent representation can significantly impact the outcome of matters such as asset division, child custody arrangements, and spousal support determinations. The availability of experienced and reputable legal professionals provides individuals navigating divorce with the assurance of skilled advocacy and informed guidance through complex legal processes. Historically, the importance of skilled legal representation in divorce cases has increased in parallel with the growing complexity of family law statutes and financial regulations.
Subsequent sections will explore the factors contributing to an attorney’s reputation in this field, methods for identifying suitable legal counsel, and the specific areas of expertise these professionals often possess.
1. Experience
Experience is a cornerstone characteristic of a highly regarded divorce attorney in Spokane. It manifests in several crucial aspects of legal practice, directly impacting case outcomes and client satisfaction. Specifically, seasoned attorneys possess a deep understanding of local court procedures, judicial preferences, and opposing counsel strategies. This nuanced knowledge allows them to anticipate potential challenges and proactively build robust legal strategies. For instance, an attorney with years of experience navigating Spokane County’s family court system will be familiar with the specific documentation requirements, filing deadlines, and common evidentiary issues that often arise.
The correlation between experience and positive case results is significant. Attorneys with a proven track record have honed their skills through handling a multitude of diverse divorce cases, ranging from amicable separations to highly contested disputes involving complex asset divisions and child custody battles. Their experience equips them to effectively negotiate settlements, prepare compelling arguments for court, and cross-examine witnesses persuasively. Consider an attorney who has successfully negotiated numerous settlements involving business valuations; their familiarity with the intricacies of financial analysis and valuation methodologies provides a distinct advantage when advocating for a fair and equitable division of assets. Similarly, an experienced attorney is less likely to be caught off guard by unexpected legal maneuvers or procedural hurdles, thus minimizing potential delays and complications.
In summary, experience is not merely a quantitative metric; it is a qualitative indicator of an attorney’s ability to effectively represent clients in divorce proceedings. The depth of knowledge, honed skills, and strategic insights gained through years of practice directly translate into tangible benefits for clients seeking optimal outcomes. While other factors contribute to an attorney’s overall reputation, experience remains a fundamental and indispensable characteristic of a premier divorce attorney in Spokane, leading to better navigation of difficult situations, and a higher probability of a satisfactory resolution.
2. Reputation
An attorney’s reputation is a crucial indicator of their standing within the legal community and among potential clients seeking divorce representation in Spokane. This reputation is not merely a matter of personal opinion but reflects a compilation of experiences, outcomes, and professional conduct observed over time. A positive reputation often stems from consistent delivery of favorable results, ethical practices, and a commitment to client advocacy. The effect of a strong reputation is that it often serves as a primary factor in client selection, as individuals are more likely to trust and engage a legal professional who is widely recognized for competence and integrity.
The importance of reputation is further amplified in the context of divorce, where emotional and financial stakes are typically high. A respected attorney often benefits from referrals from past clients, other attorneys, and even judges, reflecting a widespread confidence in their abilities. For example, if an attorney consistently demonstrates skill in negotiating complex property settlements and achieves outcomes perceived as fair and equitable, their reputation for competence in financial matters will likely grow. Conversely, an attorney with a history of ethical violations or unfavorable outcomes will struggle to maintain a positive reputation and attract new clients. This underscores the direct correlation between reputation and professional success within the specialized field of divorce law.
In conclusion, reputation is an intrinsic component of identifying superior legal counsel. It is not merely an abstract concept, but a tangible reflection of an attorney’s skills, ethics, and client commitment. The ability to assess and understand the reputation of a legal professional is therefore essential for individuals seeking effective and trustworthy representation during divorce proceedings in Spokane. A well-founded reputation serves as a reliable guide for those navigating the complexities of family law, helping them to choose counsel who can advocate effectively for their interests.
3. Communication
Effective communication is a cornerstone of competent legal representation, particularly in the emotionally charged context of divorce proceedings. The ability of a legal professional to convey information clearly, listen attentively, and maintain open lines of dialogue directly impacts the client’s understanding of the legal process, their confidence in the attorney’s guidance, and the overall outcome of the case.
-
Clarity and Accessibility of Legal Advice
A proficient divorce attorney should articulate complex legal concepts in a manner easily understood by the client. This includes explaining legal strategies, potential risks, and the implications of various decisions without resorting to unnecessary jargon. For example, an attorney might explain the process of property division in layman’s terms, detailing the difference between community and separate property and outlining potential methods of valuation. Failure to communicate clearly can lead to client confusion, mistrust, and ultimately, dissatisfaction with the legal representation.
-
Active Listening and Empathetic Understanding
Beyond simply conveying information, superior legal counsel actively listens to the client’s concerns, goals, and emotional state. This involves demonstrating empathy and understanding the unique circumstances of each case. For instance, an attorney should thoroughly understand a client’s primary concerns regarding child custody arrangements or their anxieties about financial security post-divorce. This active listening enables the attorney to tailor their legal strategy to best address the client’s individual needs and priorities.
-
Timely and Responsive Communication
Prompt and responsive communication is essential for maintaining a strong attorney-client relationship. This entails responding to client inquiries in a timely manner, providing regular updates on the progress of the case, and being readily available to address any emerging concerns. For example, an attorney should promptly inform a client of any significant court filings, settlement offers, or upcoming hearings. A lack of responsiveness can create feelings of neglect and undermine the client’s confidence in the attorney’s commitment.
-
Effective Negotiation and Advocacy
Communication extends beyond the attorney-client relationship and encompasses negotiation with opposing counsel and advocacy before the court. A skilled attorney must be able to articulate their client’s position persuasively, present compelling evidence, and effectively negotiate settlements that protect the client’s interests. For example, an attorney might use strong communication skills to negotiate a favorable spousal support agreement or to advocate for a specific parenting plan during court proceedings. Deficient communication in these areas can compromise the client’s chances of achieving a positive outcome.
In conclusion, effective communication is not merely a desirable attribute, but an essential requirement for legal professionals aspiring to be considered among the premier divorce attorneys in Spokane. Clear, empathetic, and timely communication fosters trust, empowers clients, and ultimately contributes to more favorable outcomes in divorce proceedings. The ability to communicate effectively distinguishes superior legal counsel from those who simply possess legal knowledge.
4. Negotiation Skills
Negotiation skills are paramount for a divorce attorney aspiring to be recognized among the best in Spokane. Divorce proceedings, while ultimately resolved by judicial decree if necessary, often involve significant attempts at reaching agreements outside the courtroom. Effective negotiation can lead to more amicable resolutions, reduced legal costs, and outcomes that better reflect the specific needs and priorities of the parties involved. An attorney with strong negotiation acumen can navigate complex discussions regarding asset division, child custody arrangements, and spousal support with a focus on achieving a settlement that serves the client’s long-term interests.
Consider a scenario involving a divorcing couple with a jointly owned business. An attorney lacking proficient negotiation skills might be unable to accurately assess the business’s value or effectively advocate for a fair division of its assets. In contrast, a skilled negotiator could employ various tactics, such as engaging independent appraisers, presenting compelling financial analyses, and proposing creative settlement options, to ensure the client receives an equitable share. Similarly, in child custody cases, negotiation skills are crucial for crafting parenting plans that prioritize the child’s well-being while accommodating the parents’ schedules and preferences. An attorney adept at negotiation can facilitate constructive dialogue, address potential conflicts, and find mutually agreeable solutions that minimize the disruption to the child’s life. Negotiation skills do not guarantee an agreement, but they increase the likelihood of a favorable settlement and reduce the need for costly and adversarial litigation.
In conclusion, the ability to negotiate effectively is a defining characteristic of a leading divorce attorney in Spokane. This skill enables attorneys to resolve disputes more efficiently, protect their clients’ interests, and minimize the emotional and financial toll of divorce. While courtroom advocacy remains an important aspect of divorce law, skilled negotiation often provides a more constructive and cost-effective path toward achieving a satisfactory resolution. Therefore, individuals seeking the services of a highly competent divorce attorney should carefully consider the attorney’s negotiation skills as a key factor in their selection process.
5. Courtroom Presence
Courtroom presence significantly contributes to the perception and reality of an attorney’s effectiveness in divorce proceedings. For an attorney aiming to be considered among the best in Spokane, this encompasses more than simply being present in the courtroom; it signifies a commanding and persuasive demeanor. This presence is the result of a confluence of factors, including thorough preparation, a confident delivery, and a demonstrated mastery of courtroom procedure and evidence rules. The impact of a strong courtroom presence can directly influence judicial decisions, particularly in contested cases where the judge must weigh conflicting evidence and arguments. For instance, an attorney who presents a well-organized case, anticipates opposing arguments, and remains composed under pressure can sway the court’s opinion, potentially leading to a more favorable outcome for the client. A lack of courtroom presence, conversely, can undermine even the most well-prepared legal strategy, leaving the impression of uncertainty or weakness.
The benefits of a commanding courtroom presence extend beyond influencing the judge. It can also affect the opposing counsel’s strategy and willingness to negotiate. An attorney known for their strong courtroom presence might be more likely to secure favorable settlement offers before trial, as the opposing party seeks to avoid a potentially disadvantageous courtroom confrontation. Real-life examples include cases where attorneys with a reputation for effective cross-examination and compelling closing arguments have successfully negotiated settlements that protect their clients’ interests. The practical significance of understanding the importance of courtroom presence lies in recognizing that it is a critical skill, developed through experience and training, that can significantly impact the outcome of divorce proceedings.
In summary, courtroom presence is an indispensable component of an attorney’s skillset, particularly for those seeking recognition as the best in their field. It is a multifaceted attribute that requires a combination of legal knowledge, strategic thinking, and persuasive communication skills. Recognizing and valuing courtroom presence can assist individuals in selecting legal counsel who can effectively advocate for their interests and navigate the complexities of divorce litigation. The challenge for clients is to discern authentic courtroom presence from mere theatrics, focusing instead on demonstrated competence, strategic thinking, and a consistent record of successful courtroom advocacy.
6. Legal Knowledge
The designation of legal professionals as achieving the benchmark for divorce representation in Spokane rests significantly upon their depth and breadth of legal knowledge. This competency extends beyond a mere understanding of fundamental family law principles. It encompasses a sophisticated grasp of relevant statutes, case law, and procedural rules at both the state and local levels. Superior legal knowledge allows an attorney to construct robust legal strategies tailored to the specific nuances of each case. The effectiveness of these strategies is directly tied to the attorney’s ability to apply legal principles to complex factual scenarios, anticipate potential challenges, and advocate persuasively on behalf of their client.
For example, in high-asset divorce cases, a comprehensive understanding of tax law, business valuation methodologies, and real estate regulations is essential for ensuring an equitable distribution of property. An attorney with specialized knowledge in these areas can effectively challenge opposing valuations, identify hidden assets, and negotiate settlements that protect the client’s financial interests. Consider also the complexities of child custody disputes. A skilled attorney must possess a thorough understanding of child welfare laws, parental rights, and the factors courts consider when determining the best interests of the child. This knowledge enables them to present compelling arguments regarding custody arrangements, visitation schedules, and parental responsibilities. Failure to possess such specialized knowledge can lead to suboptimal outcomes, potentially jeopardizing the client’s financial security or parental rights.
In summary, legal knowledge forms the bedrock of effective divorce representation. Its significance lies in its direct impact on case strategy, negotiation outcomes, and courtroom advocacy. Attorneys who consistently demonstrate a mastery of relevant legal principles are more likely to achieve favorable results for their clients and earn recognition within the legal community. While other factors, such as communication skills and courtroom presence, contribute to an attorney’s overall effectiveness, legal knowledge remains the indispensable foundation upon which superior representation is built.
7. Client Reviews
Client reviews serve as critical indicators for individuals seeking capable legal representation during divorce proceedings. These reviews offer insight into past client experiences, reflecting on the attorney’s professionalism, communication skills, and overall effectiveness. The aggregate of such reviews contributes significantly to forming an attorney’s reputation and influence perceptions of their suitability as premier divorce counsel in Spokane.
-
Reflecting Real-World Experiences
Client reviews provide authentic accounts of interactions with legal professionals. Unlike marketing materials, these reviews often detail the nuances of the attorney-client relationship, shedding light on aspects such as responsiveness, empathy, and the ability to explain complex legal matters in accessible terms. For instance, a review might commend an attorney for their consistent communication throughout the process, which demonstrates a commitment to keeping clients informed and involved. Conversely, negative reviews may highlight instances of poor communication, unmet expectations, or perceived lack of diligence.
-
Assessing Communication and Empathy
Divorce cases often involve heightened emotional distress. Client reviews frequently assess an attorney’s ability to communicate empathetically and provide emotional support alongside legal guidance. Reviews may praise attorneys who demonstrate understanding and sensitivity to their clients’ concerns, fostering a sense of trust and confidence. Attorneys who are perceived as dismissive or uncaring may receive negative feedback, underscoring the importance of interpersonal skills in this field. Such considerations become particularly important when evaluating claims of superiority in divorce law representation.
-
Evaluating Effectiveness and Outcomes
While specific case details are typically confidential, client reviews often provide general assessments of an attorney’s effectiveness in achieving favorable outcomes. Reviews may highlight the attorney’s ability to negotiate settlements, resolve disputes, and advocate effectively in court. Clients may express satisfaction with the attorney’s strategic thinking, attention to detail, and commitment to protecting their interests. Conversely, negative reviews may point to instances where the attorney failed to meet expectations, resulting in unfavorable outcomes or perceived mishandling of the case. Potential clients often look for a pattern of positive outcomes as an indication of an attorney’s competence.
-
Detecting Patterns and Trends
Individual client reviews may be subjective, but a collection of reviews can reveal patterns and trends that offer a more comprehensive assessment of an attorney’s strengths and weaknesses. Consistently positive reviews across multiple platforms can indicate a strong reputation for providing high-quality legal services. Conversely, a significant number of negative reviews may raise red flags and prompt further investigation. Potential clients often scrutinize the volume and consistency of reviews when selecting legal counsel. A lack of online presence or a history of negative feedback can hinder an attorney’s ability to attract new clients seeking the best divorce attorney in Spokane.
The preceding factors related to client review analysis are therefore strongly coupled with the pursuit of legal counsel who can be credibly described using the “best divorce attorney spokane” descriptor. The accumulation of positive feedback, reflecting strong communication, empathy, effectiveness, and consistent satisfaction, helps to validate an attorney’s claim of excellence in this specialized area of legal practice.
8. Specialized Expertise
The designation of a legal professional as one of the preeminent divorce attorneys in Spokane is inextricably linked to the possession of specialized expertise within distinct facets of family law. General competence in law is insufficient; instead, a demonstrable command of specific areas, such as complex asset division, business valuation, or child custody litigation involving psychological evaluations, is paramount. The attainment of the designation, best divorce attorney spokane, is frequently the result of possessing and applying specific expertise.
An attorney claiming expertise in high-asset divorce, for instance, must possess a thorough understanding of tax implications, forensic accounting, and investment strategies. This expertise enables them to accurately assess the value of diverse assets, including real estate holdings, stock options, and privately held businesses. A real-world example includes an attorney successfully challenging an opposing expert’s business valuation by identifying flaws in their methodology and presenting a more accurate assessment, resulting in a more equitable property division for their client. Similarly, in cases involving contested child custody, specialized expertise in child psychology and custody evaluations allows an attorney to effectively cross-examine expert witnesses and advocate for parenting plans that prioritize the child’s best interests. Without such focused knowledge, outcomes may be severely undermined.
In summary, specialized expertise serves as a key differentiator among divorce attorneys. It enhances their ability to navigate complex legal issues, protect their clients’ interests, and achieve favorable outcomes. While general legal knowledge is a prerequisite, specialized expertise is the defining characteristic that elevates an attorney to the top tier of divorce practitioners in Spokane. Individuals seeking legal representation should therefore carefully assess the attorney’s areas of specialization to ensure a proper fit for their specific needs, the complexity of their case, and their individual circumstances. This will improve the likelihood of a satisfactory resolution.
9. Ethical Standards
The evaluation of legal professionals to determine those meriting the descriptor “best divorce attorney spokane” necessitates rigorous examination of their adherence to ethical standards. These standards, codified in rules of professional conduct, govern attorney behavior and ensure fairness, integrity, and client protection within the legal system. Attorneys recognized as superior divorce counsel consistently demonstrate unwavering commitment to these ethical principles, thereby maintaining public trust and upholding the integrity of the legal profession.
-
Confidentiality
Maintaining client confidentiality is a fundamental ethical obligation. Divorce attorneys handle sensitive personal and financial information, and any breach of confidentiality can have severe consequences for the client. Attorneys considered top-tier rigorously protect client information from unauthorized disclosure, adhering to strict security protocols and exercising discretion in all communications. For instance, they will not discuss case details with third parties without explicit consent and will secure electronic data to prevent unauthorized access. Violation of this principle would disqualify an attorney from the “best divorce attorney spokane” designation.
-
Conflict of Interest
Divorce attorneys must avoid representing clients when a conflict of interest exists. This includes situations where representing one client would be directly adverse to the interests of another current or former client. Attorneys must conduct thorough conflict checks to identify potential conflicts and decline representation if a conflict cannot be ethically resolved. For example, an attorney should not represent a party in a divorce if they previously represented the opposing party in a related business matter. Failure to avoid conflicts of interest can undermine the attorney’s impartiality and compromise the client’s representation. An attorney that demonstrates conflict of interest will definitely not considered to be among the “best divorce attorney spokane”.
-
Candor Towards the Tribunal
Attorneys have a duty to be honest and truthful when presenting information to the court. This includes accurately representing the facts of the case, disclosing adverse legal precedents, and avoiding misrepresentations or omissions. An attorney who knowingly presents false evidence or makes misleading statements to the court violates ethical standards and undermines the integrity of the legal process. For example, an attorney cannot knowingly misrepresent a client’s income or assets to influence a spousal support determination. Upholding candor towards the tribunal is a hallmark of attorneys recognized as being among the “best divorce attorney spokane”.
-
Competence and Diligence
Attorneys must provide competent and diligent representation to their clients. This includes possessing the necessary legal knowledge and skills to handle the case effectively, conducting thorough investigations, and pursuing the client’s objectives with reasonable diligence. An attorney who neglects a client’s case, fails to meet deadlines, or lacks the necessary expertise may be deemed to have violated their ethical obligations. For instance, an attorney who fails to properly investigate a client’s financial circumstances or adequately prepare for trial may be considered incompetent. Demonstrating competence and diligence ensures only the most reliable and effective individuals will be considered “best divorce attorney spokane”.
In conclusion, ethical standards are fundamental to the practice of law, particularly in the sensitive area of divorce. Attorneys seeking recognition as being among the “best divorce attorney spokane” must consistently demonstrate unwavering adherence to these principles. Upholding confidentiality, avoiding conflicts of interest, maintaining candor towards the tribunal, and providing competent and diligent representation are essential for maintaining client trust and upholding the integrity of the legal profession. Legal practitioners violating any of these principles will compromise any claims of superiority.
Frequently Asked Questions About Engaging Divorce Counsel in Spokane
The following questions address common concerns and misconceptions regarding the selection and retention of divorce attorneys within the Spokane area. This information is intended to provide clarity and assist individuals navigating the complexities of divorce proceedings.
Question 1: What distinguishes a “best divorce attorney spokane” from other legal professionals?
The designation implies a combination of factors, including extensive experience, a proven track record of favorable outcomes, a strong reputation within the legal community, and consistent adherence to ethical standards. It reflects a demonstrated commitment to providing high-quality legal representation in divorce cases.
Question 2: How can one effectively evaluate the claims made by attorneys who self-identify as the “best divorce attorney spokane”?
Due diligence is crucial. Examine the attorney’s experience, client reviews, professional affiliations, and disciplinary record. Seek referrals from trusted sources, such as other attorneys or past clients. Schedule consultations with multiple attorneys to assess their communication style, understanding of the case, and proposed legal strategy.
Question 3: What are the typical costs associated with retaining a divorce attorney in Spokane?
Legal fees vary significantly depending on the complexity of the case, the attorney’s experience, and the billing arrangement. Attorneys may charge hourly rates, flat fees, or a combination of both. Request a detailed fee agreement outlining the attorney’s billing practices and potential costs before engaging their services.
Question 4: What factors should be considered when assessing an attorney’s “courtroom presence” during divorce proceedings?
Courtroom presence encompasses an attorney’s demeanor, preparedness, and ability to present persuasive arguments and effectively examine witnesses. Assess their communication skills, strategic thinking, and demonstrated mastery of courtroom procedure and evidence rules.
Question 5: Is it necessary to engage an attorney with specialized expertise in complex financial matters for a high-asset divorce?
For high-asset divorces, specialized expertise is highly recommended. An attorney with knowledge of tax law, business valuation, and forensic accounting can effectively navigate complex financial issues and protect the client’s financial interests.
Question 6: What recourse is available if an attorney violates ethical standards during divorce proceedings?
If an attorney violates ethical standards, a formal complaint can be filed with the Washington State Bar Association. The bar association will investigate the complaint and take disciplinary action if warranted, which may include suspension or disbarment.
Engaging competent and ethical legal counsel is paramount for achieving a fair and equitable outcome in divorce proceedings. Careful consideration of the factors outlined above can assist individuals in selecting the most suitable attorney for their specific needs.
Subsequent sections will address specific areas of divorce law and strategies for navigating common challenges.
Expert Guidance for Navigating Divorce in Spokane
The subsequent recommendations are designed to offer strategic insights for individuals undergoing divorce proceedings within the Spokane legal landscape. These suggestions emphasize proactive measures and informed decision-making.
Tip 1: Prioritize Documentation
Meticulously gather and organize all relevant financial documents, including bank statements, tax returns, investment records, and property deeds. This documentation forms the foundation for accurate asset valuation and equitable property division. Lack of proper documentation can extend legal proceedings and provide room for an unfair division of assets.
Tip 2: Understand Legal Rights and Obligations
Become thoroughly informed regarding spousal rights and obligations under Washington State law. This includes understanding community property principles, spousal maintenance guidelines, and child custody considerations. Gaining detailed knowledge from reliable legal counsel will allow for comprehensive, informed participation in the legal proceedings.
Tip 3: Secure Independent Financial Advice
Consult with a qualified financial advisor to assess the long-term financial implications of proposed settlement agreements. This is particularly important in cases involving complex assets or significant retirement accounts. Seek a professional who has no conflict of interest to evaluate your current and future financial stability.
Tip 4: Preserve Communication Records
Maintain a detailed record of all communications with the divorcing spouse, including emails, text messages, and voicemails. These records can serve as valuable evidence in support of claims or to refute allegations during legal proceedings. Keep a log of all communication with the other party, in case it becomes important during mediation or litigation.
Tip 5: Protect Credit Rating
Take steps to protect individual credit rating during the divorce process. This may involve separating joint accounts, managing debt responsibly, and monitoring credit reports for any unauthorized activity. The outcome of divorce cases will affect the credit rating so be mindful of debts and financial decisions.
Tip 6: Prioritize Child’s Well-being
In cases involving children, prioritize their emotional and psychological well-being above all else. Avoid involving children in the divorce proceedings or exposing them to parental conflict. Consult with a child psychologist or counselor if needed to provide support and guidance.
Tip 7: Consider Mediation or Collaborative Divorce
Explore alternative dispute resolution methods, such as mediation or collaborative divorce, as a means of reaching a settlement outside of court. These processes can often be more efficient, cost-effective, and less adversarial than traditional litigation.
Implementing these recommendations can significantly enhance the likelihood of achieving a favorable and equitable outcome in divorce proceedings. Adherence to these guidelines will contribute to a more informed and strategic approach.
The subsequent section will provide a conclusion summarizing key considerations for individuals facing divorce in Spokane.
Concluding Remarks on Divorce Representation in Spokane
The preceding analysis has explored the multifaceted considerations involved in identifying competent and ethical legal counsel within the Spokane divorce law arena. The designation of “best divorce attorney spokane” implies a constellation of attributes, including experience, reputation, communication skills, negotiation abilities, courtroom presence, legal knowledge, ethical standards, specialized expertise, and positive client reviews. No single factor defines such a designation; rather, it reflects a holistic assessment of an attorney’s professional capabilities and commitment to client service.
Individuals contemplating or undergoing divorce proceedings should carefully weigh the factors discussed herein when selecting legal representation. The selection of qualified and ethical counsel can significantly impact the outcome of divorce cases, affecting financial security, parental rights, and overall well-being. Prudent investigation and thoughtful deliberation are essential for navigating this complex legal process effectively. The future well-being of those involved is reliant on effective representation and counsel.
